It’s a holiday scene seemingly as old as time, family gatherings with relatives traveling great distances to be with their loved ones. Grandparents (especially) can’t wait to get reacquainted with their young grandchildren. At some point, one of the grandparents (often the grandfather) asks their young grandchild, ‘so what do you want to be when you grow up?”
Teacher, firefighter, musician, forest ranger, nurse, ball player, lawyer are just a few of the responses that the youngster might give. The grandparent, no doubt, is pleased—sensing their grandchild has given this important question some thought. Of course, this is all in spite of their young age and the likelihood that they’ll incessantly change their mind.
Yet, the grandparent has unknowingly perpetuated a misconception on the part of the grandchild. The problem started with the question the grandparent asked. Notice that the youngster actually answered a different question than the one posed by the grandparent.
The question the youngster answered was “what do you want to do when you grow up?” In other words, the youngster likely told their grandparent what interested them and how they envisioned earning a living (e.g. firefighter, teacher, forest ranger, etc) pursuing that interest.
The grandparent didn’t catch (or didn’t appreciate) the subtle, but important, distinction between being and doing— let alone point it out to the youngster. How one earns a living is one thing, but it isn’t who they are—it doesn’t reveal what kind of person they are. Young people would be well served to understand that distinction.
Unfortunately, the experience with the grandparent subtly reinforces to the grandchild that what they do for a living largely defines who they are. Of course, grandparents have a lot of company when it comes to this phenomenon….it’s no wonder, with all the emphasis on ‘career-mania’ in this country.
The fact that the youngster didn’t ‘get it’ is understandable, predictable really—given their young age.
All together now (in unison)—“what we do for a living, doesn’t define who we are.” ‘Doing’ and ‘being’ are different!
For all the sacrifice parents (and some grandparents) make to ensure a first-rate education for their children; for all the blood-sweat-and–tears on the part of the diligent student; for all the prestige society puts in performing certain types of work…being is equally important (if not more so) than doing.
Part two, which will be posted in a little over two weeks, will illustrate how one Southern California school has brought this important point to life.