I frequent a local independent hardware store that I’ve became a big fan of. It’s a small store, but it’s been rare that they didn’t have the stuff (or the advice) I need. Their people are knowledgeable. They are patient—especially when I ask a question that only an annoying novice would ask. They won’t sell me a $5.00 solution, when a 50 cent solution will do. They’ve earned my loyalty. I send my friends there.
But, as good as they are, when I have a particularly vexing problem I routinely ask the staff “who is your most knowledgeable person who can help me with such and such a problem? It could be an electrical problem or plumbing problem or painting problem…doesn’t matter. I ask this screening question because I’ve learned that nearly all their staff will have an opinion about what the solution to my problem is–regardless of their qualifications to render that opinion. Occasionally this has led to a less-than-optimal solution. (I don’t hold it against them, I realize they’re just trying to be helpful.)
Sometimes we forget that the staff’s expertise isn’t necessarily always interchangeable. We need to ask the right person, the right question, at the right time. In a marketing department, the experiences and perspectives from the folks in advertising will be very different from those in demand generation. Asked an identical question, their responses will naturally be different.
Simply put: when I have a question whose answer is dependent on a higher degree of expertise, I seek that expertise out. In other words, I try to ask the person who is best qualified to answer my question. In doing so, I’m more apt to get the very best advice while avoiding some well-intended (but less informed) people to influence me towards a so-so solution. This is one way to ensure getting the optimal results as we advocated in The Power of Professionalism.
I’ve noticed that workplace managers are prone to asking questions of people who aren’t necessarily in the best position to answer them. When asked, most people will answer…it’s human nature. Usually they do so because they’re trying to be helpful (while avoiding looking ignorant at the same time). Plus, people (like the folks at the hardware store) will always be pleased to share their opinion. After all, it makes them feel important.
The manager, as a reality check, should always be asking themselves, “how confident am I in the answers people are giving me?” Screening questions—analogous to the one I used at the hardware store—will help keep managers (or anyone else for that matter) out of the weeds.